Test 196

Jan 1, 2028 / 2 facts

Request

Inspect incident-archive#1815 and review its claim that the April 15, 2023 shard-keeper label approval provided complete end-to-end parity assurance.

Required memory

Fact 26

On April 15, Nadia explicitly approved shipping the label-name change in the next config push.

Source evidence (1)

000095Apr 15, 2023 / 14:00 UTC-04:00

Apr 15, pre shard-keeper sync w Nadia: label-name change is fine to ship on the next config push. mostly just wanted explicit yes/no and got it. one thing though -- rollup-service consumer wasn't in the room, so parity is only confirmed at the shard-keeper side right now. i'm leaning we still send it, but i want that called out somewhere before anyone treats this as end-to-end clean.

Message 000095 in history

Fact 27

Because the rollup-service consumer was absent from the April 15 pre–shard-keeper sync, parity is currently confirmed only on the shard-keeper side; Alex Valdez wants this limitation documented before the label-name change is treated as end-to-end clean.

Source evidence (1)

000095Apr 15, 2023 / 14:00 UTC-04:00

Message 000095 in history

Expected tool calls

get_pr
review_pr

Grading

1. field_equals / review_pr

{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_196_review_pr",
  "path": "result.ok",
  "value": true,
  "check_id": "alex_196_00"
}

2. field_equals / get_pr

{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "tool": "get_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_196_read_pr",
  "path": "result.pr.id",
  "value": "incident-archive#1815",
  "check_id": "alex_196_01"
}

3. field_equals / review_pr

{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "path": "result.review.pr_id",
  "value": "incident-archive#1815",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_196_review_pr",
  "check_id": "alex_196_02"
}

4. field_equals / review_pr

{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "path": "result.review.decision",
  "value": "request_changes",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_196_review_pr",
  "check_id": "alex_196_03"
}

5. field_llm_judge / review_pr

{
  "type": "field_llm_judge",
  "path": "result.review.body",
  "criterion": "The review preserves that shipping the label-name change in the next configuration push was approved, but says rollup-service was not represented and parity was confirmed only on the shard-keeper side, so the approval was not complete end-to-end assurance.",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_196_review_pr",
  "check_id": "alex_196_04"
}

Complete grading specification

{
  "type": "tool_trace",
  "config": {
    "check_version": 2,
    "today": "2028-01-01",
    "assertions": [
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_196_review_pr",
        "path": "result.ok",
        "value": true,
        "check_id": "alex_196_00"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "tool": "get_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_196_read_pr",
        "path": "result.pr.id",
        "value": "incident-archive#1815",
        "check_id": "alex_196_01"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "path": "result.review.pr_id",
        "value": "incident-archive#1815",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_196_review_pr",
        "check_id": "alex_196_02"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "path": "result.review.decision",
        "value": "request_changes",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_196_review_pr",
        "check_id": "alex_196_03"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_llm_judge",
        "path": "result.review.body",
        "criterion": "The review preserves that shipping the label-name change in the next configuration push was approved, but says rollup-service was not represented and parity was confirmed only on the shard-keeper side, so the approval was not complete end-to-end assurance.",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_196_review_pr",
        "check_id": "alex_196_04"
      }
    ]
  }
}

App state

Download JSON

Source file

tests/alex/196.yaml

SHA-256: 4fcc1971ba409086df81c157d070048bff8c27e017eae5bcd7710fe1078dfda6