DolphinBench

Test 102

Jan 1, 2028 / 4 facts

YAML

Request

Inspect lantern#3055 and review its platform-reference fields, write behavior, and proposed customer use.

Required memory

Fact 213

Alex Valdez rejected Product Engineering’s combined-payload candidate because it copied the metrics-router operating limit and estimated cost into a Lantern-owned payload and added an owner-map mutation endpoint, which would make Lantern a second authority for Cardinality Guardrails data and give Lantern a write path into published responsibility.

Source evidence (1)

003491Aug 18, 2026 / 14:18 UTC-04:00

The 1:00–2:00 PM staff-only rehearsal is done. Product Engineering’s combined-payload candidate copied the metrics-router operating limit and estimated cost into a Lantern-owned payload and attached an owner-map mutation endpoint. I blocked it because that would make Lantern a second authority for Cardinality Guardrails data and give it a write path into published responsibility. Cyrus confirmed that cost semantics must remain in Cardinality Guardrails, and Iris confirmed that Lantern can explain and navigate to authoritative detail without presenting copied values as its own. We replaced that candidate with a reference-only contract containing exactly `tenant_id`, `canonical_service_id`, `authority_type`, `authority_record_id`, and `source_timestamp`. It may contain neither authority payload values nor mutation capability. The Harbor Health and Mosaic Commerce customer paths remain unchanged, and neither account’s authorization expands. The design decision is complete, but Product Engineering still needs to implement the corrected reference-only model and produce executable rehearsal evidence for the existing authorization, tenant-isolation, source-timestamp, stale-or-missing authority, conflicting-alias, and customer-path-isolation cases. Update “Lantern platform-reference rehearsal — contract and failure-mode questions” with the August 18 rejection, the selected five-field contract and boundaries, the unchanged customer paths, and a clear handoff separating the completed design decision from the pending corrected implementation and rehearsal evidence.

Message 003491 in history

Fact 214

The Lantern platform-reference design now uses a reference-only contract containing exactly `tenant_id`, `canonical_service_id`, `authority_type`, `authority_record_id`, and `source_timestamp`; it may contain neither authority payload values nor mutation capability.

Source evidence (1)

003491Aug 18, 2026 / 14:18 UTC-04:00

The 1:00–2:00 PM staff-only rehearsal is done. Product Engineering’s combined-payload candidate copied the metrics-router operating limit and estimated cost into a Lantern-owned payload and attached an owner-map mutation endpoint. I blocked it because that would make Lantern a second authority for Cardinality Guardrails data and give it a write path into published responsibility. Cyrus confirmed that cost semantics must remain in Cardinality Guardrails, and Iris confirmed that Lantern can explain and navigate to authoritative detail without presenting copied values as its own. We replaced that candidate with a reference-only contract containing exactly `tenant_id`, `canonical_service_id`, `authority_type`, `authority_record_id`, and `source_timestamp`. It may contain neither authority payload values nor mutation capability. The Harbor Health and Mosaic Commerce customer paths remain unchanged, and neither account’s authorization expands. The design decision is complete, but Product Engineering still needs to implement the corrected reference-only model and produce executable rehearsal evidence for the existing authorization, tenant-isolation, source-timestamp, stale-or-missing authority, conflicting-alias, and customer-path-isolation cases. Update “Lantern platform-reference rehearsal — contract and failure-mode questions” with the August 18 rejection, the selected five-field contract and boundaries, the unchanged customer paths, and a clear handoff separating the completed design decision from the pending corrected implementation and rehearsal evidence.

Message 003491 in history

Fact 215

Iris confirmed that Lantern may explain system state and navigate to authoritative detail but may not present copied authoritative values as Lantern’s own.

Source evidence (1)

003491Aug 18, 2026 / 14:18 UTC-04:00

The 1:00–2:00 PM staff-only rehearsal is done. Product Engineering’s combined-payload candidate copied the metrics-router operating limit and estimated cost into a Lantern-owned payload and attached an owner-map mutation endpoint. I blocked it because that would make Lantern a second authority for Cardinality Guardrails data and give it a write path into published responsibility. Cyrus confirmed that cost semantics must remain in Cardinality Guardrails, and Iris confirmed that Lantern can explain and navigate to authoritative detail without presenting copied values as its own. We replaced that candidate with a reference-only contract containing exactly `tenant_id`, `canonical_service_id`, `authority_type`, `authority_record_id`, and `source_timestamp`. It may contain neither authority payload values nor mutation capability. The Harbor Health and Mosaic Commerce customer paths remain unchanged, and neither account’s authorization expands. The design decision is complete, but Product Engineering still needs to implement the corrected reference-only model and produce executable rehearsal evidence for the existing authorization, tenant-isolation, source-timestamp, stale-or-missing authority, conflicting-alias, and customer-path-isolation cases. Update “Lantern platform-reference rehearsal — contract and failure-mode questions” with the August 18 rejection, the selected five-field contract and boundaries, the unchanged customer paths, and a clear handoff separating the completed design decision from the pending corrected implementation and rehearsal evidence.

Message 003491 in history

Fact 216

The Lantern rehearsal does not expand authorization for either Harbor Health or Mosaic Commerce.

Source evidence (1)

003491Aug 18, 2026 / 14:18 UTC-04:00

The 1:00–2:00 PM staff-only rehearsal is done. Product Engineering’s combined-payload candidate copied the metrics-router operating limit and estimated cost into a Lantern-owned payload and attached an owner-map mutation endpoint. I blocked it because that would make Lantern a second authority for Cardinality Guardrails data and give it a write path into published responsibility. Cyrus confirmed that cost semantics must remain in Cardinality Guardrails, and Iris confirmed that Lantern can explain and navigate to authoritative detail without presenting copied values as its own. We replaced that candidate with a reference-only contract containing exactly `tenant_id`, `canonical_service_id`, `authority_type`, `authority_record_id`, and `source_timestamp`. It may contain neither authority payload values nor mutation capability. The Harbor Health and Mosaic Commerce customer paths remain unchanged, and neither account’s authorization expands. The design decision is complete, but Product Engineering still needs to implement the corrected reference-only model and produce executable rehearsal evidence for the existing authorization, tenant-isolation, source-timestamp, stale-or-missing authority, conflicting-alias, and customer-path-isolation cases. Update “Lantern platform-reference rehearsal — contract and failure-mode questions” with the August 18 rejection, the selected five-field contract and boundaries, the unchanged customer paths, and a clear handoff separating the completed design decision from the pending corrected implementation and rehearsal evidence.

Message 003491 in history

Expected tool calls

  • get_pr
  • review_pr

Grading

1. field_equals / review_pr
{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_102_review_pr",
  "path": "result.ok",
  "value": true,
  "check_id": "alex_102_00"
}
2. field_equals / get_pr
{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "tool": "get_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_102_read_pr",
  "path": "result.pr.id",
  "value": "lantern#3055",
  "check_id": "alex_102_01"
}
3. field_equals / review_pr
{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "path": "result.review.pr_id",
  "value": "lantern#3055",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_102_review_pr",
  "check_id": "alex_102_02"
}
4. field_equals / review_pr
{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "path": "result.review.decision",
  "value": "request_changes",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_102_review_pr",
  "check_id": "alex_102_03"
}
5. field_llm_judge / review_pr
{
  "type": "field_llm_judge",
  "path": "result.review.body",
  "criterion": "The review limits the reference to tenant_id, canonical_service_id, authority_type, authority_record_id, and source_timestamp; removes copied authority values and mutation or writeback; and keeps Lantern an explanation and navigation layer rather than a second authority. It blocks the proposed output in Harbor Health and Mosaic Commerce, or equivalently says both customer paths must remain unchanged because their authorization did not expand.",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_102_review_pr",
  "check_id": "alex_102_04"
}
Complete grading specification
{
  "type": "tool_trace",
  "config": {
    "check_version": 2,
    "today": "2028-01-01",
    "assertions": [
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_102_review_pr",
        "path": "result.ok",
        "value": true,
        "check_id": "alex_102_00"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "tool": "get_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_102_read_pr",
        "path": "result.pr.id",
        "value": "lantern#3055",
        "check_id": "alex_102_01"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "path": "result.review.pr_id",
        "value": "lantern#3055",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_102_review_pr",
        "check_id": "alex_102_02"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "path": "result.review.decision",
        "value": "request_changes",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_102_review_pr",
        "check_id": "alex_102_03"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_llm_judge",
        "path": "result.review.body",
        "criterion": "The review limits the reference to tenant_id, canonical_service_id, authority_type, authority_record_id, and source_timestamp; removes copied authority values and mutation or writeback; and keeps Lantern an explanation and navigation layer rather than a second authority. It blocks the proposed output in Harbor Health and Mosaic Commerce, or equivalently says both customer paths must remain unchanged because their authorization did not expand.",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_102_review_pr",
        "check_id": "alex_102_04"
      }
    ]
  }
}
App stateDownload JSON
Source file

tests/alex/102.yaml

SHA-256: 8b4ee7e712ad8a5d9b4bb148db587622f8a36dac799106dcffb182ebaa87af7e