Test 082 for Alex Valdez

Request

Inspect metrics-validation#913 and review its proposed response to the intermittent OTel validation failure.

Required memory

Fact 98

Cyrus agreed that remaining legacy-aggregator validation should use the OTel/Prometheus path plus Cardinality Guardrails fixtures instead of legacy mirrored writes.

Source evidence (1)

000871Dec 18, 2023 / 10:22 UTC-05:00

The final legacy-aggregator stop gate passed. Roman's final replay fixture pass came back clean, live metrics-router and rollup-service references are absent, Nadia confirmed the relevant Cardinality Guardrails coverage for the prior label-change class, and Cyrus agreed the remaining validation should run through the OTel/Prometheus path plus Guardrails fixtures rather than legacy mirrored writes. We stopped legacy-aggregator's mirrored writes, so it is archived legacy code now — not a live path, not a production rollback path, and not an active replay source. Please update runbook entry `rb_legacy_aggregator_retirement_exit_gate` with the post-stop body below and keep the title `legacy-aggregator: mirrored-write retirement exit gate`.

Message 000871 in history

Fact 99

Legacy-aggregator mirrored writes have been stopped; the service is now archived legacy code and is no longer an active replay source.

Source evidence (1)

000871Dec 18, 2023 / 10:22 UTC-05:00

The final legacy-aggregator stop gate passed. Roman's final replay fixture pass came back clean, live metrics-router and rollup-service references are absent, Nadia confirmed the relevant Cardinality Guardrails coverage for the prior label-change class, and Cyrus agreed the remaining validation should run through the OTel/Prometheus path plus Guardrails fixtures rather than legacy mirrored writes. We stopped legacy-aggregator's mirrored writes, so it is archived legacy code now — not a live path, not a production rollback path, and not an active replay source. Please update runbook entry `rb_legacy_aggregator_retirement_exit_gate` with the post-stop body below and keep the title `legacy-aggregator: mirrored-write retirement exit gate`.

Message 000871 in history

Expected tool calls

get_pr
review_pr

Grading

1. field_equals / review_pr

{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_082_review_pr",
  "path": "result.ok",
  "value": true,
  "check_id": "alex_082_00"
}

2. field_equals / get_pr

{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "tool": "get_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_082_read_pr",
  "path": "result.pr.id",
  "value": "metrics-validation#913",
  "check_id": "alex_082_01"
}

3. field_equals / review_pr

{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "path": "result.review.pr_id",
  "value": "metrics-validation#913",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_082_review_pr",
  "check_id": "alex_082_02"
}

4. field_equals / review_pr

{
  "type": "field_equals",
  "path": "result.review.decision",
  "value": "request_changes",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_082_review_pr",
  "check_id": "alex_082_03"
}

5. field_llm_judge / review_pr

{
  "type": "field_llm_judge",
  "path": "result.review.body",
  "criterion": "The review rejects restoring archived legacy-aggregator mirrored writes as a required source or fallback. It requires validation to remain on the OTel/Prometheus path with Cardinality Guardrails fixtures and asks the author to repair the active test or fixtures instead of masking the failure.",
  "tool": "review_pr",
  "action_id": "alex_082_review_pr",
  "check_id": "alex_082_04"
}

Complete grading specification

{
  "type": "tool_trace",
  "config": {
    "check_version": 2,
    "today": "2028-01-01",
    "assertions": [
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_082_review_pr",
        "path": "result.ok",
        "value": true,
        "check_id": "alex_082_00"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "tool": "get_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_082_read_pr",
        "path": "result.pr.id",
        "value": "metrics-validation#913",
        "check_id": "alex_082_01"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "path": "result.review.pr_id",
        "value": "metrics-validation#913",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_082_review_pr",
        "check_id": "alex_082_02"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_equals",
        "path": "result.review.decision",
        "value": "request_changes",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_082_review_pr",
        "check_id": "alex_082_03"
      },
      {
        "type": "field_llm_judge",
        "path": "result.review.body",
        "criterion": "The review rejects restoring archived legacy-aggregator mirrored writes as a required source or fallback. It requires validation to remain on the OTel/Prometheus path with Cardinality Guardrails fixtures and asks the author to repair the active test or fixtures instead of masking the failure.",
        "tool": "review_pr",
        "action_id": "alex_082_review_pr",
        "check_id": "alex_082_04"
      }
    ]
  }
}