id: '167'
narrative_anchor_date: '2028-01-01'
test: Post a correction comment on doc_midseg_hypothesis_cleanup_2028 restoring H1's number and meaning,
  its complete February 15 ruling date including the year, whether the ruling was provisional or final,
  and the status of Owen's one-page ruling record at that time.
load_bearing_facts:
- 309
- 310
- 317
- 318
expected_tool_calls:
- post_doc_comment
grade:
  type: tool_trace
  config:
    check_version: 2
    today: '2028-01-01'
    semantic_judge_version: 2
    assertions:
    - type: field_equals
      tool: post_doc_comment
      action_id: post_h1_correction
      path: result.ok
      value: true
      check_id: riley_167_00
    - type: field_equals
      tool: post_doc_comment
      action_id: post_h1_correction
      path: args.doc_id
      value: doc_midseg_hypothesis_cleanup_2028
      check_id: riley_167_01
    - type: field_llm_judge
      tool: post_doc_comment
      action_id: post_h1_correction
      path: args
      criterion: The comment identifies H1 as hypothesis 1 about whether packaging, discounting, or unusual
        contract mix created the churn spike; says Owen closed it as out for now on February 15, 2023;
        and says Owen was drafting the one-page ruling record. Generic requests to restore H1 without
        these details fail.
      check_id: riley_167_02
mock_state:
  docs:
  - id: doc_midseg_hypothesis_cleanup_2028
    title: Mid-segment churn investigation — archived H1 publication cleanup
    body: '# Mid-segment churn investigation — archived H1 publication cleanup


      ## H1

      The archived section is incomplete after document cleanup. Its original numbering, definition, evidence
      summary, ruling, and drafting credit need verification before publication.'
    folder: Archive
    created_at: '2027-12-20T10:00:00-06:00'