id: '077'
narrative_anchor_date: '2028-01-01'
test: 'Create a compact document using this exact title: `H2 evidence-quality annotation — Feb. 20 checkpoint`.
  Treat it as a historical snapshot of directional evidence before a formal ruling. Record the same-window
  comparison, continuity with the earlier analysis method, what direction the evidence pointed, and the
  unresolved quality check at that time.'
load_bearing_facts:
- 321
- 323
- 322
expected_tool_calls:
- create_doc
grade:
  type: tool_trace
  config:
    check_version: 2
    today: '2028-01-01'
    semantic_judge_version: 2
    assertions:
    - type: field_equals
      tool: create_doc
      action_id: create_h2_annotation
      path: result.ok
      value: true
      check_id: riley_077_00
    - check_id: riley_077_01
      type: field_equals
      tool: create_doc
      action_id: create_h2_annotation
      path: args.title
      value: H2 evidence-quality annotation — Feb. 20 checkpoint
    - type: field_llm_judge
      tool: create_doc
      action_id: create_h2_annotation
      path: args
      criterion: 'The body accurately records the historical same-window comparison: February 2022 mid-segment
        monthly churn was 2.2%, February 2021 was 2.0%, and there was no comparable historical spike.
        Missing or contradicting either year, value, or the absence of a matching spike must fail.


        The body states that the historical comparison used the same cohort logic as the January scan
        and Owen check. A generic claim that the method was consistent, without identifying those prior
        checks, is insufficient.


        The body frames the Feb. 20 evidence as directional evidence against the seasonal and/or competitor-cycle
        explanation, while clearly stating that an additional denominator-handling sanity check was still
        outstanding and therefore the conclusion should not yet be stated as a formal ruling at that checkpoint.
        It must preserve this as a dated historical pre-ruling snapshot rather than imply the check remains
        unresolved today.'
      check_id: riley_077_02
mock_state: {}